Propaganda In The Helping Professions

The book "Propaganda in the Helping Professions" by Eileen Gambrill is a critical look at the ways in which the helping professions have been infiltrated by propaganda. The book covers a variety of topics, from phrenology to institutional crib-beds for adult psychiatric patients, from Roman bird-beak masks to drugs designed to combat overurination. The book is written in a clear and engaging style, and it provides a comprehensive overview of the ways in which propaganda has infiltrated the helping professions. The book is a must-read for anyone in the helping professions, as well as for consumers who want to be able to make informed decisions about their treatment.

Propaganda in the helping professions has grown by leaps and bounds in recent decades, with alarming implications for clients and their families, as well as the professionals who try to help them. There is a fog that has been generated by corporate interests and organizations attempting to sell their services and products to desperate or poorly educated consumers. Propaganda in the Helping Professions is a guide to lifting the confusion. From phrenology to institutional crib-beds for adult psychiatric patients, from Roman bird-beak masks to drugs designed to combat overurination, readers are taken on a tour across the centuries of egregious practices of professionals and quacks including the present-day medicalization of our lives. The author, one of the field's most relentless critics of fads, phonies, and fallacies, shows readers how to think critically about both research and advertising in order to deliver effective services to clients and not be bamboozled by bogus claims about alleged problems, risks, and remedies. Incisive, interesting, eminently readable, and passionately argued, this book places responsibility for client well-being both on consumers-to raise questions-and on the professionals who claim to help them-to accurately answer them. Review: I know of no other work that so masterfully reviews propaganda and deceptive scholarship in all its guises and illustrates how it characterizes so much of what passes as 'help, ' 'therapy, ' or 'science' in the helping professions. In addition, the final chapters expand the analysis into a magnificent primer on identifying deception and doublespeak in the literature. As commercial and ideological conflicts of interest in the helping enterprise have largely blurred the boundary between science and marketing, this book should be required reading for all helpers and would-be helpers, their clients, and those who aspire to be critical thinkers. -- David Cohen, PhD, Florida International University I would have to describe Eileen Gambrill as 'the Rachel Carson of health and public policy.' This is a wonderful book, written with an engaging literary style from a liberal perspective, but as hardnosed as can be when dealing with questions of evidence, on the tendency of vested interests to distract us for their own essentially undemocratic ends. The book is testimony to the fact that soft-heartedness about the human condition need not imply soft-headedness when making evidence-influenced plans to try to assist. -- Brian Sheldon, PhD, University of Exeter I can think of no greater accolade than to state how much this book stirred me to think, and of how much I learned from reading it. This is a brilliant book. Every practitioner in the human services and, more importantly, every literate client, should read it. It provides an effective antidote to the pervasive propaganda to be found relating to the causes of psychosocial and biologically based disorders, their assessment, and treatment. A wonderful addition to the literature on scientific skepticism. -- Bruce A. Thyer, PhD, Florida State University Propaganda in the Helping Professions is a book that needed to be written and that should be mandatory reading for all consumers. We are dr